Modern Western and Classical Islamic Legal Methodologies on the Axis of Codification and Ijtihad

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23037329

Keywords:

Islamic Law, Modern Law,, Ijtihad, Codification, Enlightenment

Abstract

This study comparatively examines the fundamental characteristics of the Islamic legal (Fiqh) paradigm in relation to the modern Western legal paradigm. These characteristics, which can also be interpreted under the rubric of legal philosophy, reflect the underlying mentalities, objectives, and inherent natures of both Islamic and Western law. According to the findings of this research, while modern Western law with its centralized, uniformist and hegemonic nature is designed primarily for corporate organization, namely the state; Islamic law with its decentralized, pluralistic, and liberationist nature is designed rather for the private person, specifically for human life. While the rationalist and state-oriented structure of Western law conceptualizes law as a body of norms dictated top-down, Islamic law advocates a horizontal plurality compatible with social dynamics through the civil activity of “ijtihad”. In this context, the study focuses on the profound divergence between the sources and ultimate goals of these legal systems. Any attempts at comparison or synthesis between the two systems cannot be undertaken without considering these antithetical characteristics. Consequently, by focusing on the ontological question of for whom law is designed (the state or the individual?), this article opens a theoretical discussion on the tension between the modernity’s conception of law and the libertarian structure of classical Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh).

References

Austin, J., 1995. The Province Of Jurisprudence Determined. (W. E. Rumble, Ed.), Cambridge University Press.

Bauman, Z., 1991. Modernity and Ambivalence. Cornell University Press, New York.

Bayartan, M., 2008. Osmanlı Şehirlerinde Vakıflar ve Vakıf Sisteminin Şehre Kattığı Değerler. Osmanlı Bilimi Araştırmaları Dergisi, X/1, İstanbul.

Çizakça, M., 2000. A History of Philanthropic Foundations: The Islamic World from the Seventh Century to the Present. Boğaziçi University Press, İstanbul.

Dworkin, R., 1986. Law’s Empire. Harvard University Press. Cambridge, Massachusetts, London, England.

Deleuze, G., 1992. Postscript on the Societies of Control. Journal October 59 (Winter 1992).

Escobar, A., 1995. Encountering Development: The Making and Unmaking of the Third World. Princeton University Press, Princeton.

Ez-Zerkâ, M. A., 1968. Al-Fiqh al-Islami fi thawbihi al-jadid [Islamic jurisprudence in its new mantle]. (Vol. 1), Dar al-Fikr, Damascus.

Feldman, N., 2008. The Fall and Rise of The Islamic State. Princeton University Press.

Foucault, M., 1977. Discipline and Punish: The Birth of The Prison. Translated Alan Sheridan, Pantheon Books, New York.

Hallaq, W. B., 2009. An Introduction to Islamic Law. Cambridge University Press.

Hallaq, W. B., 2013. The Impossible State: Islam, Politics, and Modernity's Moral Predicament. Columbia University Press.

Hallaq, W. B., 2012. The Sharī'a: Theory, Practice, Transformations. Cambridge University Press.

Hart, H. L. A., 1961. The Concept of Law. Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Heper, A., 2015. Postmodernizm ve Hukuk -Kısa Bir Bakış-, Hukuk Kuramı, 2/2,1-6, https://www.hukukkurami.net/editor/Sayi_8/08_01_heper.pdf (Erişim: 11.06.2026).

Hobbes, T., 1996. Leviathan. (R. Tuck, Ed.), Cambridge University Press.

İbn Âşûr, M., T., 2013. İslâm Hukuk Felsefesi, Gaye Problemi. Çev. Vecdi Akyüz- Mehmet Erdoğan, 4. Baskı, Rağbet Yayınları, İstanbul.

İhsanoğlu, E., 1999. Osmanlı Medeniyeti Tarihi. 1. Cilt, (Osmanlı Eğitim ve Bilim Müesseseleri) (“Institutions of Learning and Science in the Ottoman Empire”. History of the Ottoman State, Society & Civilisation), Feza Yayıncılık, Düzenleme: IRCICA, İstanbul.

Iqbal, M., 1954. The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam. Bookseller And Publisher, Kashmiri Bazar- Lahore.

Kamali, M. H., 2003. Principles of Islamic jurisprudence. Islamic Texts Society, Cambridge.

Kelsen, H., 1949. General Theory of Law and State. Translated By: Anders Wedberg, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Kelsen, H., 1967. Pure Teory of Law. Translated by from second Geman Edition: Max Knight, University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles.

Montesquieu, C. S., 2023. The Sipirit of Laws. Wimbledon Publishing Company, London.

Pierson, C., 2004. The Modern State. Routledge, Second Edition, New York.

Poggi, G., 2005. Modern Devletin Gelişimi. Çev. Şule Kurt - Binnaz Toprak, 3. Baskı, Bilgi Üniversitesi Yayınları, İstanbul.

Santos, B., S., 2002. Toward a New Legal Common Sense: Law, Globalization, and Emancipation. 2. Edition, Butterworths LexisNexis, Cambridge University Press, London.

Schacht, J., 1964. An introduction to Islamic law. Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Şâban, Z., 2020. İslam Hukuk İlminin Esasları (Usûlü'l-Fıkh). Çev. İbrahim Kâfi Dönmez, 34. Baskı, Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı Yayınları, Ankara.

Şâtıbî, 1990. el-Muvâfakât: İslâmî İlimler Metodolojisi. 4 Cilt. Çev. Mehmet Erdoğan, İz Yayıncılık, İstanbul.

Şehristâni, E., M., A., 1990. el-Milel ve’n-Nihal, Daru’l-Kütubi’l-İlmiyye, Beyrut.

Watson, A., 1993. Legal Transplants: An Approach to Comparative Law. 2. Baskı, University of Georgia Press, Athens.

Weber, M., 1978. Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology. University of California Press. Berkeley, Los Angeles, California.

Weiss, B. G., 1992. The search for God's law: Islamic jurisprudence in the Writings of Sayf al-Din al-Amidi. University of Utah Press.

Weiss, B. G., 2006. The spirit of Islamic law. University of Georgia Press.

Yükselbaba, Ü., 2016. Postmodernizm ve Hukuk. İÜHFM, LXXIV/1, İstanbul.

Published

2026-09-29

How to Cite

TÜRKER, A. (2026). Modern Western and Classical Islamic Legal Methodologies on the Axis of Codification and Ijtihad. ISPEC International Journal of Social Sciences & Humanities, 10(3), 323–333. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23037329

Issue

Section

Articles